2024: HERSEY 2, Conant 0
2023: PALATINE 2, Buffalo Grove 1
2022: Fremd 1, ELK GROVE 0
2021 (fall): FREMD 3, Hersey 0
2021 (spring): Barrington 1, BUFFALO GROVE 1
(Barrington wins PKs) 
2020: No Game (COVID)
2019: FREMD 7, Wheeling 1
2018: BUFFALO GROVE 2, Fremd 0
2017: BARRINGTON 0, Buffalo Grove 0 (BARRINGTON  wins PKs)
2016: WHEELING 3, Barrington 2 (OT)
2015: SSCHAUMBURG 2, Buffalo Grove 0
2014: Fremd 1, WHEELING 0
2013: Wheeling 1, BARRINGTON 1 (Wheeling wins PKs)
2012: Palatine 1, BUFFALO GROVE 1 (Palatine wins PKs)
2011: Prospect 1, SCHAUMBURG 1 (Prospect wins PKs)
2010: Fremd 3, ELK GROVE 1
2009: PALATINE 5, Prospect 1
2008: HERSEY 0, Barrington 0 (HERSEY wins PKs)
2007: Hersey 1, BARRINGTON 1 (Hersey wins PKs)
2006: HERSEY 3, Fremd 2 (OT)
2005: PALATINE 2, Hersey 0
2004: Barrington 2, PROSPECT 1
2003: BARRINGTON 4, Hersey 0
2002: Conant 3, HERSEY 2
2001: Hersey 1, CONANT 0
2000: Conant 1, BUFFALO GROVE 0
1999: CONANT 3, Rolling Meadows 2
1998: ROLLING MEADOWS 1, Fremd 0
1997: CONANT 2, Hersey 2 (Conant wins PKs)
1996: Schaumburg 2, Fremd 1
1995: Schaumburg 2, Wheeling 1 (OT)
1994: Palatine 1, Prospect 0
1993: Fremd 1, Hoffman Estates 1 (Fremd wins PKs)
1992: Fremd 3, Conant 1
1991: Palatine 4, Conant 0
1990: Palatine 2, Rolling Meadows 0
1989: Hoffman Estates 3, Buffalo Grove 1
1988: Buffalo Grove 3, Rolling Meadows 2
1987: Fremd 1, Rolling Meadows 0
1986: Hoffman Estates 3, Fremd 2 (OT)
1985: Palatine 2, Hoffman Estates 1
1984: Hoffman Estates 2, Palatine 1
1983: Fremd 3, Hoffman Estates 1
1982: Fremd 1, Hoffman Estates 0
1981: Forest View 2, Wheeling 0
1980: Forest View 2, Fremd 1
1979: Palatine 5, Forest View 2
1978: Forest View 3, Palatine 1
1977: Wheeling 5, Forest View 2
1976: Fremd vs. Forest View (no game)

NOTE: The championship match was known as the Soccer Bowl from 1976-2006. In 2007, the name of the game was changed Soccer Cup to have more of a soccer feel rather than an American-style name.